THE DEVELOPMENT OF ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES AND STANDARDS (AN EMPIRICAL STUDY)

By

OMONONYE NDUDI ANDY

Presented To

Department of Accountancy

ABSTRACT

The objective of this study is to access based on empirical research the exceptional qualities or otherwise of the present accounting principles and standards.

Information was drawn from both primary and secondary sources. The primary sources were held with members of institute of chartered accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) on the subject matters. During the time, question on the general field of accounting principles and development were asked. The rest of the information came from library sources. The information collected was analysis using simple tabular diagrams, percentages, ratio and statistical tools chi-square. The result obtained from this study is that the present way of evolving accounting principles and standard from the beginning which dates back to 600BC has not been very helpful. The study also revealed the economic life of business differ significantly so that the purpose or aims of financial reports are not the same everywhere. All these have resulted to display in the financial report between accounts.

Although, it is evident that a quest deal of success has been recorded by the accountancy, bodies worldwide, in standardizing existing standards. This project recommends that a standard based on contemporary problem and fashioned for the immediate or particular business environment be evolved. It is hoped that when the points mentioned above are fully implemented, the accountancy profession, especially in Nigeria which is currently being threatened by existing laws in the country, can effectively render those necessary committee it owes to the public it services. By way of reward for the this services, the future existences of the profession would be guaranteed as it would remain ever strong and reliable.

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1: Statement of standard Accounting practice (SSAP)

Table 2 Reconciliation

Table 3 Questionnaire administrative and received

Table 4 The disclosure of Accounting Policies and information and the producers and users in the understanding and interpretation of financial statement and the making of economic decision (SAS) 1 and 2

Table 5 Does the use of several method for valuing and reporting stock, give rise to wide differences in total result of the operations of enterprises in the same line of business (SAS4)

Table 6 Will the accounting for employee retirement benefits help in determination of the amount due to employees before or after the date of implementation of plans (SAS8)

Table 7 Will the accounting for depreciation provide a guide for uniform and acceptable method of determining and reporting depreciation on items? (SAD9)

Table 8 Is there need for review of the accounting principles and standards to reflect contemporary problem?

Table 9 The environment of the practice of accounting profession as presented by the companies and Allied matters decreed is a result of tact of trust in the professional accounting in Nigeria

Table 10 In your own opinion were the thirteen standard launched by the Nigeria Accounting standard board (NASB) actually developed by were they mere modification of UK SSAP"

Table 11 Is there need for a review of the accounting principles and standards to reflect contemporary problems?

Table 12 The encroachment of the practice of accounting profession as presented by the companies and allied matter decree is as a result of lack of trust in the professional competence of professional accountants in Nigeria

Table 13 Chi-Square table

Table14 Chi-Square table

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title page ii

Approval page iii

Dedication iv

Acknowledgement v

Abstract vi

List of tables viii

Table of contents x

CHAPTER ONE

Introduction 1

11 overview of study 1

12 Statement of problem 5

13 Objective of study 6

14 Hypothesis of the research 7

15 Significance of the study 8

16 Limitation of the study 9

17 Definition of terms 9

Reference 12

CHAPTER TWO

Review of related literature 13

21 Historical development of accounting 13

211 The early financial accounting 13

212 The venture accounting 15

213 The joint stock company 16

22 Development of accounting principles and standards 18

23 Recent revisions to accounting standards 23

24 Foreign currency transaction and conversion 25

25 Accounting for depreciation 26

26 Accounting for lease and hire purchase 28

References 31

CHAPTER THREE

Research methodology 33

31 sources of data 33

311 Primary data 33

312 Secondary data 33

32 Population and sample size 34

33 Methodology used 35

CHAPTER FOUR

Presentation and Analysis of Data 38

41 presentation and analysis of an empirical research into

the accounting principle and standards 38

42 Testing of hypothesis 46

CHAPTER FIVE

Summary of Finding Recommendation and Conclusion 62

51 Recommendation 64

52 Conclusion 67

Bibliography 68

Questionnaire 71

CHAPTER ONE

11 OVERVIEW OF STUDY

The hall mark of a profession is its commitment to the public service The commitment can be classified into three Firstly, there must be satisfaction of the society being served, secondly there must be professional pride invite craft and thirdly the profession should be accorded recognition be fond its national boarders

If we go down into memory, we discover that the need for better accounting principles and standards is a world wide phenomenon, for instance, Noel Hyndman and Robert kink (1989:20) said that one of the main reasons for the dearth of new standards and revisions of same is the fact that the accounting standard committee (ASC) like other standard setting bodies now begin to investigate accounting topics which are extremely controversial Invariably, most of the new standards involve significant adjustments to both the profit and loss account and the valuation of assets and liabilities in the balance sheet

Again, Noel Hyndman and Robert kink (1989:42-44) on then part saw from every practical objective level, most countries have disconvered lack of clear statement of the aims and purpose of financial reporting as the major, short coming in the standard setting processes According to Hyndman and kink, and citing germany as an example, "financial statement are considered as one of the most important vehicles for communicating with people who have financial interest in business enterprises" The art of accounting in this circumstances unlike the (former) is to provide a reliable and relevant information to the interested parties

Explaining his own reaction on the global effect of clear statement of the aims and purposes called, "in the united states for example, the stock market crashes of 1929 and 1969 which was blamed on financial report by companies first triggered the estblishment of accounting standard in that country" He went further to say that in the UK, like Nigeria the establishment of accounting standard committee (ASC) by the six professional bodies were ignited by lack of uniform Nigerian situation was made worse by the Nigerian enterprises promotions decree which attempted to transfer ownership of companies to Nigeria" Foreighers exploited the lack of uniform accounting procedure in valuing their equity in corporations affected by the decree Practicing accountant is faced to go down memory lane once more, he may admit that the problem emanated from their evolvement of those principles and standards that date back to 600 BC, when accounting as a practice came into being Ordinarily, he may resolve that all it takes to improve on the principles is a fough body of accounting standards But could these forestall the disasters in the accounting world most especially in our country?

Today, the disaster is becoming more real than apparent in Nigeria with the introduction of the secondary foreign exchange market (SFEM), the recent open market operation (OMD) and foreign exchange market (FEM) According to Okpechi 91990:5) this system has brought in its wake a lot of pressures on management of companies to show profits in the fact of rapidly dwindling revenues Accounts are most likely going to be massaged and manipulated to show favourable result Once more, it is in this regard that accounting standards of measurement and reporting and the need for more to be more responsive to developed principles assume greater importance

If members of the profession feel that the present principles and standards have not altogether done much good, shall helplessly ching to them or find something that would be benefical to helping to achieve consistency between standard After all December 20^th century dictionary (1985:1022 AND 1261) pointed out the three major qualities of all principles and standard, it defined principles as "consistent regulation of behaviour accord go moral law" and standards as accepted authorities statement of adequacy required According to Oxford English Dictionary second edition volume xii (1991:499) principles is defined as a "general law or rule adopted or professed as a guide to action, a settled ground or basis of conduct or action, especially one consciously recognized and followed and standards as a definite level of excellence, attainment, wealth or the lay or a definite degree of any quality, viewed as a presaribed object of ondeavour or as a measure if what is adequate for some purpose Form the foregoing, one may deduce that principles or standard is consistency applied if it provides adequate treatment for items in question The adequacy assume its acceptability and the circle contnues here lies our problem The primary aim of this project, therefore is to find something we could expect would lead to a cutting back of alternative treatments in a longer term In the short come closer to which could be regarded as our yearning principles or philosophy Put simple a better account standard evolved to solve our immediate problems This standard is also expected to fit into the economic like of particular place in question

12 STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Okpechi statement presents one of the problems of this thesis I have been tempted many times, to dispel certain newspaper misconception about why the Nigerian accounting standard Board was established and how The standard developed so far are carbon copies of those produced elsewhere"…

(Okpechi 1990:2)

so, the first of the needs of this project is to see how accounting principles development based on our local problems instead of reinventing the present principles with its shortcomings

Again, the study would take a meticutons look at the trend of standards development and revision of the world over, and seek ideal devices of providing good standards of measure and reporting that would remove distrust and attract more acceptance from the public we serve

Finally, the urgent need to hormonize and standardize the skills and knowledge acquired by Nigerians who studied in the two contrasting economies of competitive market of the west or the planned economy for the East would be tackled This is done to achieve uniformity in the treatment and reporting of accounting information Among others, it hopes to introduce measures which will enhance the reliability and validity of information reporting in the financial statement

13 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

David Allem, (1989:35-48) made it clear that given the rapid globalization of business in recent years, it seems reasonable to predict that an effective system of accounting for danging price levels and other economic uncertainties must address the present economic situation Taking that as on premise, this study hopes to change those practical detents which are traceable to the difficulties of narrowing areas of difference in practices The aim is to ensure that financial statements that are presented to both local and foreign users are structurally uniform and meaningful

Secondly, it hopes to hance accounting standards and hence accounting information that reflects our economic environment but at the same time, satisfies the anticipated needs of the users of the information Among others, it hopes to introduce measures which will enhance the reliability and validity of information reported in the financial statements

14 HYPOTHESIS OF THE RESEARCH

In order to guide the researcher in planning the course of this in quality in choosing the necessary data in deciding the appropriate statistical treatment and in examining the outcome of this study, the following hypothesis were formulated:

1 Hi: There is need for review of the accounting principles and standards to reflect contemporary problems

2 Hi: Lack of trust in the professional competence of promulgation of the companies and allied matters Decree

3 HI: Thirteen accounting standards launched by the Nigeria accounting standard Board were mere carbon copies of those produce elsewhere?

15 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY

The word 'Empirical" attached to this study "The development of accounting principles and standard was defined in the 20^th centrury chamber dictionary as the system which reflecting all knowledge, vest solely on experience and induction "(Kink Patrick 1943: 409) Taking this as premise, the meaning or importance of this project lies on the light quality thoughts of protocohe members of the profession relating to the use of present day accounting principles and standards

As we have rightly been informed, some failure in the current standards all over the world have compelled members of the profession, to seek ways of correcting them In the process, they discovered that lack of clear statement of the aims and purposes of financial statement is because economic life differs from other country to country This in turn has led to disparities in the standards and quality of practice between accountants This letter has a strong effect on the profession because it has resulted to doubt from the public which we server, as to how competent we are Therefore, this study has its importance, very strong quest to be satisfied, and it goes thus: in the face of above divergent conditions and situations, is THERE NO MEANS WE CAN EVOLVE STANDARD FASHIONED FOR THE CONTEMPORARY PERIOD AND ALSO FOR A SPECIFIC ECONOMIC LIFE?

16 LIMITATION OF THE STUDY

The sample size is restricted to Nigeria only even though the study went beyond the national boarders The reason advanced for a professed as a guide to action, especially one consciously recognized and followed; and standards as a definite level of excellence attainment, whether or the like or a definite degrees of any equality viewed as a prescribed object

17 DEFINITION OF TERMS

The main thrust of this chapter is to look closely at what different authorities are saying on the topic view

According to Okpechi (1990:3) accounting is the application of standards of procedures transactions and procedures and methods in order to reflect the impact of transactions and conditions on the financial position of an enterprise"

On standard, we described it as reference points to which other measures are expected to confirm" (Okpechi, 1990:2)

Garbutt Douglas 91984:0101) sees accounting as a discipline concerned with the recording, analysis and forecasting of income and wealth of business and other entities He went further to define accounting principles as the rale and conventions which have been adopted as a general guide action by the accountancy profession "On accounting standards he regards it as methods of accounting approved by the authoritative bodies in whose departure the financial effect should be disclosed and explained'

Besides, Lawrence Isung (1990:14) and Nwoko Chinedu (1990:1-3) have similar definitions as one above, but went beyond to distinguish between concepts and principles as contain in the statement of accounting standards

Referring to the statement, Isung work about Accounting concept saying "concepts qualified as fundamental and are the underpinning of the preparation and presentation of financial statement and principles as the rule that accountants must follow when it becomes necessary to exercise judgment about the choice and the application of conflicting fundamental concept The forgoing seems to be saying that accounting principles and standards are off-shoos or conventions deprived from experience of years ago

A background knowledge of those past experiences in the accounting profession becomes apparent, if one must judge contemporary issue correctly

REFERENCES

1 Allen D (1986) Accounting for charging price level international Dimension management, Accounting The bulletin of the Accounting standard committee, United Kingdom Page 116

2 Garbutt D (1984) Carter's Advance Account 7^th edition (Great Britain Pitman Publishing Inc) page 85 - 90

3 Isung L (1990) "Development of Accounting principles and Concepts studies in Accontancy Text and Reading(Enugu New age Publishers page 5-13

4 Nwoko C (1990) Historical Development of Accounting studies in Accountancy Text and Reading (Enugu New age Publishers)

5 Hyndman and Kirk (1986) The latest Accounting standard Bulletin of the Accounting standard committee United Kingdom page 920

6 Osisioma B (1990) Studies in Accountancy Test and Reading, New Age Publishers Page 50-56

7 Okpechi O (1986) Accounting for changing price level international Dimension "Management standard committee United Kingdom Page 41-48