A LEGAL AND JURISPRUDENTIAL ANALYSIS OF HOMOSEXUALITY AND SAME SEX MARRIAGES: SUPPORTING THE NIGERIAN POSITIION

By

Author

Presented To

Department of Law

A LEGAL AND JURISPRUDENTIAL ANALYSIS OF HOMOSEXUALITY AND SAME SEX MARRIAGES:  SUPPORTING THE NIGERIAN POSITIION

ABSTRACT

APPROVAL

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title Page                                                                                        i

Certification                                                                                    ii

Approval                                                                                         iii

Dedication                                                                                       iv

Acknowledgement                                                                         v

Table of Contents                                                                            vii

CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION

11     Definition of Homosexuality                                                         1

12     Who is a Homosexual?                                                                   16

13     What is Marriage?                                                                18

14     Forms of Same-Sex Marriages                                             26

15     Same-Sex Marriage in Contradistinction with Purpose

of Marriage in the Ordinary Sense                                               30

CHAPTER TWO: LAW AND MORALITY IN RELATION TO HOMOSEXUALITY AND SAME MARRIAGES

21     The Moral Implication of Homosexuality and Same-Sex

Marriage                                                                                35

22     Moral Implication of Homosexuality in Nigeria               47

CHAPTER THREE

31     Anti-Homosexuality and Same-Sex Marriage

Legislations in Nigeria                                                                  56

32     Attempts by the Nigerian Legislature and People

to Stopping the Scourge                                                        59

CHAPTER FOUR:  OPINION ACROSS THE WORLD

41     Social and Legal View Point of Homosexuality

Around the World History                                                  68

42     Social and Legal View Point of Homosexuality

in America                                                                                       72

CHAPTER FIVE:  CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

51     Conclusion                                                                            78

52     Recommendations                                                              81

Bibliography                                                                                  82

CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

11     DEFINITION OF HOMOSEXUALITY

Homosexuality is romantic or sexual attraction or behavior between members of the same sex or gender  As an orientation, homosexuality refers to “an enduring pattern of or disposition to experience sexual, affectionate, or romantic attractions” primarily or exclusively to people of the same sex; “it also refers to an individual’s sense of personal and social identity based on those attractions, behaviours expressing them, and membership in a community of others who share them” [1]

Homosexuality is one of the three main categories of sexual orientation, along with bisexuality and heterosexuality, within the heterosexual-homosexual continuum (with sexuality sometimes considered a fourth)  Scientific and medical understanding is that sexual orientation is not a choice, but rather a complex interplay of biological and environmental factors, especially with regard to early uterine environment[2]  While there are those who still hold the view that homosexual activity is “unnatural” or “dysfunctional”[3] research has shown that homosexuality is an example of normal variation in human sexuality and is not in and of itself a source of negative psychological effects  Prejudice and discrimination against homosexual and bisexual people, however, have been shown to cause psychological harm[4]

The most common terms for homosexual people are lesbian for females and gay for males, though gay is also used to refer generally to both homosexual males and females  The number of people as gay or lesbian and the proportion of people who have same-sex sexual experiences – are difficult for researchers to estimate reliably for a variety of reasons[5]  According to major studies, 2% to 10% of people have had some form of same-sex sexual contact within their lifetime[6]  In a 2006 study, 20% of respondents anonymously reported some homosexual feelings, although only 2-3% identified themselves as homosexual  Homosexual behavior is also observed in many non-human animal species[7]

Many gay and lesbian people are in committed same-sex relationships, though only recently have census forms and political conditions facilitated their visibility and enumeration[8]  These relationships are equivalent to heterosexual relationships in essential psychological respects[9]  Homosexual relationships and acts have been admired, as well as condemned, throughout recorded history, depending on the form they took and the culture in which they occurred  Since the end of the 19th century, there has been a global movement towards increased visibility, recognition and legal rights for homosexual people, including the rights to marriage and civil unions, adoption and parenting, employment, military service, equal access to health care, and the introduction of anti-bullying legislation to protect LGBT minors

Societal attitudes towards same-sex relationships have varied over time and place, from expecting males to engage in same-sex relationships, to casual integration, through acceptance, to seeing the practice as a minor sin, repressing it through law enforcement and judicial mechanisms, and to proscribing it under penalty of death

In a detailed compilation of historical and ethnographic materials of Preindustrial Cultures, “strong disapproval of homosexuality was reported for 41% of 42 cultures; it was accepted or ignored by 21%, and 12% reported no such concept  Of 70 ethnographies, 59% reported homosexuality absent or rare in frequency and 41% reported it present or not uncommon”[10]

In cultures influenced by Abrahamic religions, the law and the church established sodomy as a transgression against divine law or a crime against nature  The condemnation of anal sex between males, however, predates Christian belief  It was frequent in ancient Greece; “unnatural” can be traced back to Plato[11]

Many historical figures, including Socrates, Lord Byron, Edward II, and Hadrian,[12] have had terms such as gay or bisexual applied to them; some scholars, such as Michael Foucault, have regarded this as risking the anachronistic introduction of a contemporary construction of sexuality foreign to their times, though others challenge this[13] [1] Case No S147999 in the Supreme Court of the State of California, in re Marriage Cases Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No 4365(…) APA California Amicus Brief – As filed” (http://wwwcourtscagov/documents/Amer_Ass_Amicus_Curiae_Brief pdf page 10  Retrieved 2010-12-21

[2] Royal College of Psychiatrists:  Submission to the Church of England’s Listening Exercise on Human Sexuality (http://wwwrepsychacuk/pdf/submission%20the%2020Church% Church%20England,pdf)

[3] Robinson, BA (2010) “Divergent beliefs about the nature of homosexuality” (http://wwwreligioustoleranceorg/hom_fixehtm)

[4] America Psychological Association:  Resolution on Appropriate Affirmative Responses to Sexual Orientation Distress and Change Efforts (http://wwwapaorg/about/governance/council /policy/sexual-orientationaspx)

[5] LeVay, Simon (1996)  Queer Science; The Use and Abuse of Research into Homosexuality (http://wwwwashingtonpostcom/wp-srv/style/longterm/books/chap/queersciencehtm)

[6] Investigators ACSF (1992) “AIDS and sexual behavior in France”  Nature 360 (6403): 407-409, doi: 101038/360407a0  (http://dxdoiorg/1038%2F360407a0), PMID 1448162

[7] Science Daily:  Same-Sex Behaviour Seen in Nearly All Animals (http://wwwsciencedailycom/ releases/2009/06/0906122106aspx)

[8] Census Statistics show quarter of California same-sex couples raising kids (http://wwwmercurynewscom/census/ci_18334802?nclick_check=1)  homosexuality

[9] Case No S147999 in the Supreme Court of the State of California, in re Marriage Cases Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No 4365(…) APA California Amicus Brief – As filed” (http://wwwcourtscagov/documents/Amer_Ass_Amicus_Curiae_Briefpdf page 10  Retrieved 2010-12-21

[10] Adolescence and puberty, by John Bancroft, June Machover Reinisch, p 162

[11] “…sow illegitimate and bastard seed in courtsesans, or sterile seed in males in defiance of nature”  Plato in THE LAWS (Book VIII p 841 edition of Stephanus) or p 340 edition of Penguin Books, 1972

[12] Roman Homosexuality  By Craig Arthur Williams, p 60  homosexuality

[13] Hubbard Thomas K (2003-09-22)  “Review of David M Halperin, How to Do the History of Homosexuality”  Bryn Mawr Classical Review homosexuality