INFLUENCE OF MOBILE MARKETING ON CONSUMER PURCHASE BEHAVIOUR IN ORGANIZED INSTITUTIONS IN LAGOS STATE, NIGERIA
By
AKINBODE MOSUNMOLA OLUWAFUNMILAYO (CU021120010)
Presented To
Department of Business Administration and Management
ABSTRACT
Advances in Information and Communication Technologies are not only offering new
marketing channels of communication and interactivity to companies but also significantly influencing the ways in which organisations conduct their businesses and marketing activities. Marketing on Mobile devices has become one of the most popular channels of communicating with intending and potential customers, particularly in the form of text advertising through Short Messaging Service. This study is aimed at examining the influence of mobile Marketing on consumer Purchase Behaviour among mobile phone users in organized institutions in Lagos State. The objectives of this study are to examine the effect of marketing messages on consumer attitude, to identify the effect of marketing messages on purchase behaviour and to examine consumer factors that significantly influence attitude towards mobile marketing. To achieve the objectives, four hypotheses were formulated from the structure of the research questions. This study was anchored on three theories: learning theory, involvement theory, and theory of reasoned action. The study employed cross-sectional survey design and the data required for this study were gathered using a structured questionnaire. One thousand two hundred (1200) copies of the questionnaire were administered to University students and employees in selected organisations. One thousand and forty three (1043) copies were retrieved out of which One thousand and twenty (1020) copies were used for analysis. Validity
and reliability of the research instrument was carried out using composite reliability,
content and construct validity. Multi-stage sampling and systematic random sampling techniques were used to select the respondents for this study. Multiple regression was used to test the stated hypothesis with the use of structural modeling technique. The first hypothesis revealed that there is a significant positive effect of marketing messages on consumer attitude (C.R values were greater than 1.96 and P values less than 0.05). The second hypotheses revealed that consumer attitude towards marketing messages have a positive influence on purchase behaviour (C.R values were greater than 1.96 and P values less than 0.05). The third hypothesis revealed that there is a significant positive effect of marketing messages on purchase
behaviour (C.R values were greater than 1.96 and P values less than 0.05). The fourth hypothesis tested revealed that there is a significant influence of consumer factors (except for innovativeness, existing knowledge and social norms) on attitude towards marketing messages (C.R values were greater than 1.96 and P values less than 0.05). Based on these findings, the study recommended that: (i) mobile marketing managers should determine target customers and understand their demographic characteristics in order to develop successful mobile marketing
programmes and strategies; (ii) Marketing messages should be personalized to consumer needs in stimulating positive attitude and response towards the advertised product/service; (iii) Marketers should frequently communicate with their customers in order to build customer loyalty; (IV) organizations and advertisers should seek consumers consent before sending them marketing messages, as mobile phones are considered personal assets to the owners; (v) Organisations should ensure that their marketing messages are creatively designed in order to yield value to the consumer.
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page
Title Page ii
Certification iii
Declaration iv
Dedication v
Acknowledgements vi
Abstract ix
Table of Contents x
List of Tables xiii
List of Figures xvi
List of Charts xvii
List of Models xviii
List of Appendices xix
List of Abbreviations xx
CHAPTER ONE:
INTRODUCTION
11 Background to the Study 1
12 Statement of Research Problem 3
13 Research Questions 5
14 Research Objectives 6
15 Research Hypotheses 6
16 Significance of the Study 6
17 Scope of Study 7
18 Outline of Chapters 8
19 Operationalization of Research Variables 9
110 Definition of Terms 11
CHAPTER TWO:
LITERATURE REVIEW
21 Conceptual Framework 12
211 The Nigerian Telecommunication Industry 13
212 What is Mobile Marketing 15
213 Development of Mobile Marketing 17
214 Characteristics of the Mobile Phone 19
215 Mobile Marketing Tools 20
216 Short Message Service as a Mobile Marketing 21
217 Drivers of Mobile Marketing 22
218 Benefits of Mobile Marketing 22
219 Types of Mobile Marketing 26
2110 Forms of Mobile Marketing Tools 27
2111 Fundamental Issues in Mobile Marketing 33
2112 Marketing Strategy in Mobile Marketing 39
2113 Application of Marketing Mix Concept in Mobile Marketing 44
2114 Consumer Behaviour 50
2115 Marketing Communication Effects 73
2116 Factors Influencing Attitude towards Mobile Marketing 76
2117 Behavioural Intention 86
2118 Relationship between Attitude, Intention and Purchase
Behaviour 87
2119 Consumer Attitude Models in Mobile Marketing 88
22 Theoretical Framework 93
2 21 Theories of Mobile Service Adoption 93
222 Theories of Consumer Behaviour 100
23 Empirical Framework 109
24 Gap in Literature 119
CHAPTER THREE:
METHODOLOGY
31 Study Area 122
32 Research Design 123
33 Population of the Study 123
34 Sample Size Determination 124
35 Sampling Technique 124
36 Sampling Frame 127
37 Sources of Data 127
38 Data Collection Method and Procedure 128
39 Research Instrument and Design 129
310 Validity of Research Instrument 136
311 Reliability of Research Instrument 138
312 Method of Data Analysis 139
CHAPTER FOUR:
DATA PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS
41 Presentation of Data 142
411 Response Rate 142
42 Data Analysis and Interpretation 144
421 Analysis of Demographic Data 144
422 Descriptive Analysis of Data on Mobile Phone usage 147
423 Respondents Rate of Receiving Mobile Marketing Messages 158
424 Respondents Preference Density for Mobile Marketing Messages 161
425 Respondents Behavioural Response to Marketing Messages 167
426 Descriptive Analysis of data on Relevant Variables 172
422 Collation and Analysis of Open-ended Questions 183
435 Descriptive Analysis of Variables 185
43 Validation of Research Model and Testing of Hypothesis 195
431 Test of Hypothesis One 202
432 Test of Hypothesis Two 205
433 Test of Hypothesis Three 206
434 Test of Hypothesis Four 208
435 Discussion of Results 210
CHAPTER FIVE:
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
511 Summary of Work 215
52 Discussion of Findings 216
521 Summary of Theoretical Findings 216
522 Summary of Empirical Findings 218
5 3 Conclusion 222
541 Implication of Findings 224
541 Implication for Practice 224
542 Policy Makers and Government 226
55 Recommendations 227
56 Limitations of the Study 228
57 Suggestions for Further Research 230
58 Contribution to Knowledge 232
REFERENCES 234
LIST OF TABLES
Table 21: Legal Consideration for Mobile Marketing 38
Table 22: Comparison of Selected Age Cohorts across
Marketing-Related Issues 54
Table 23: Reference Group influence on Consumption 80
Table 24: Hierarchy of Effects of Different Involvement Levels 82
Figure 25: Summary of research findings on consumer attitude
towards mobile marketing 117
Table 31: Selected Sample of the Study 126
Table 32: Questionnaire Administration 129
Table 33: Measurement of Variables - Part 1- Section A 131
Table 34: Measurement of Variables - Section B 131
Table 35: Measurement of Variables - Part 2 132
Table 36: Source of Items Used in the Questionnaire 134
Table 41: Frequency Distribution by number of Questionnaires
Administered and Retrieved according to Organisations 143
Table 42: Frequency Distribution of Respondents by Socio- demographic
Characteristics 144
Table 43: Percentage Distribution of Respondents by Rate of Receiving
Marketing Message 159
Table 44: Percentage Distribution of Respondents by Preference Density to
Marketing Message 161
Table 45: Frequency Distribution of Respondents by Behavioural
Response to Marketing Message 167
Table 46: Percentage Distribution of Respondents Behavioural Response to
Marketing Messages by Gender 168
Table 47: Percentage Distribution of Respondents Behavioural Response to
Marketing Messages by Age 169
Table 48: Percentage Distribution of Respondents Behavioural Response to
Marketing Messages by Educational Qualification 170
Table 49: Percentage Distribution of Respondents Behavioural Response to
Marketing Messages by Occupation 171
Table 410: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Promotional
SMS Messages 172
Table 411: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Relational
SMS Messages 173
Table 412: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Personalization
of SMS Messages 173
Table 413: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Interactivity
of SMS Message 174
Table 414: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Frequency
of SMS Message 175
Table 415: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Brand Awareness 175
Table 416: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Intention/Actual
Purchase of Mobile Products 176
Table 417: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Loyalty 177
Table 418: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Consumer Attitude
to Mobile Marketing 177
Table 419: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Innovative Factor 178
Table 420: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Existing Knowledge of
Mobile Technology (EK) Factor 178
Table 421: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Attitude towards
Advertising 179
Table 422: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Privacy and
Permission Factor 179
Table 423: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Perceived
Credibility Factor 180
Table 424 Percentage Distribution of Responses to Perceived Risk Factor 180
Table 425: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Trust Factor 181
Table 426: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Perceived value Factor 181
Table 427: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Social Norms Factor 182
Table 428: Percentage Distribution of Responses to Consumer Satisfaction 183
Table 429: Respondents View on Challenges in Mobile Marketing
Practitioners 183
Table 430: Respondents’ Opinion on how Organizations using
Mobile Marketing can Improve on their services 184
Table 431: Descriptive Analysis of Promotional Variable 185
Table 432: Descriptive Analysis of Relational Variable 186
Table 433: Descriptive Analysis of Personalization Variable 186
Table 434: Descriptive Analysis of Interactivity Variable 187
Table 435: Descriptive Analysis of Frequency Variable 187
Table 436: Descriptive Analysis of Awareness Variable 188
Table 437: Descriptive Analysis of purchase intention and Actual purchase 188
Table 438: Descriptive Analysis of Loyalty Variable 189
Table 439: Descriptive Analysis for Innovativeness 190
Table 440: Descriptive Analysis for Existing knowledge of Mobile
Technology 190
Table 44: Descriptive Analysis for Attitude towards advertising 190
Table 442: Descriptive Analysis for Privacy and Permission 191
Table 443: Descriptive Analysis for Credibility 192
Table 444: Descriptive Analysis for Perceived Risk 192
Table 445: Descriptive Analysis for Trust 192
Table 446: Descriptive Analysis for Perceived Value 193
Table 447: Descriptive Analysis for Social Norms 193
Table 448: Descriptive Analysis for Consumer Attitude towards
Mobile Marketing 194
Table 449: Goodness of Fit Measures of the Research Models 196
Table 450ai: Reliability, Average Variance Extracted (AVE) and Correlation
Among Constructs in the model 197
Table 451bi: Factor Loadings of items included in the Model 198
Table 452ci: Average Variance Extracted (VE) and Squared Multiple
Correlations (SMC) of Items in the Model 198
Table 453a: Regression Weights for test of Hypothesis 1 202
Table 453b: Standardized Path Coefficients for test of Hypothesis 1 202
Table 453c: Squared Multiple Correlations for test of Hypothesis 1 203
Table 454a: Regression Weights for test of Hypothesis 2 205
Table 454b: Standardized Path Coefficient for test of Hypothesis 2 205
Table 455a: Regression Weights for test of Hypothesis 3 206
Table 455b: Standardized Path Coefficients for test of Hypothesis 3 207
Table 455c: Squared Multiple Correlations for test of Hypothesis 3 207
Table 456a: Regression Weights for test of Hypothesis 4 209
Table 456b: Standardized Path Coefficients for test of Hypothesis 4 209
Table 456c: Squared Multiple Correlations for test of Hypothesis 4 209
Table 457: Summary of Test of Hypotheses Findings 210
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 21: Mobile Advertising Value Chain 32
Figure 22: Framework of Mobile Marketing Environment 41
Figure 31 Stages of Sampling Technique 125
Figure 41 Test of Hypothesis 1 203
Figure 42 Test of hypothesis 2 205
Figure 43 Contribution of Marketing Messages to Purchase Behaviour 207
LIST OF CHARTS
Chart 21: The Learning Curve 60
Chart 41 Frequency distribution of Respondents by Mobile phone Usage 146
Chart 42 SMS Phone Usage by Gender 147
Chart 43 Voice calls Phone Usage by Gender 148
Chart 44 MMS Phone Usage by Gender 148
Chart 45 Videos Phone Usage by Gender 149
Chart 46 Usage of Mobile Phone News Service by Gender 149
Chart 47 Sports Phone Usage by Gender 150
Chart 48 Facebook Phone Usage by Gender 150
Chart 49 Mobile Web browsing by Gender 151
Chart 410 Mobile Phone Chatting by Gender 151
Chart 411 Mobile E-mail by Gender 152
Chart 412 Voice calls Phone Usage by Age group 153
Chart 413 SMS Phone Usage by Age group 153
Chart 414 MMS Phone Usage by Age group 154
Chart 415 Mobile Phone News Usage by Age Group 155
Chart 416 Mobile Chatting News Usage by Age Group 155
Chart 417 SMS Phone Usage by Occupation 156
Chart 418 Mobile Web browsing Usage by Occupation 157
Chart 419 SMS Service Usage by Educational Background 158
Chart 420 Respondents Preference Density for Marketing Messages
Ages (15-24) 163
Chart 421 Respondents Preference Density for Marketing Messages by
Ages (25-34) 164
Chart 422 Male Respondents Preference Density for Marketing Messages 165
Chart 423 Female Respondents Preference Density for Marketing Messages 166
LIST OF MODELS
Model 11: Research Hypotheses Model 10
Model 21: The Consumer Behaviour Model 50
Model 23: The Perceptual Process 64
Model 24 Stages in Consumer Decision-Making Process 69
Model 25 The Search for Information 70
Model 26 Security Risks in the Business Chain 85
Model 27 Brackett, and Carr (2001) Model of Consumer attitude
toward Web Advertising 89
Model 28 Tsang et al, (2004) Model of Consumer attitude
toward Mobile Marketing 89
Model 29 Haghirian and Madlberger (2005) Model of Consumer Attitude
Toward Advertising via Mobile Devices 90
Model 210 XU Model of Factors Affecting Attitude and Intention
toward Mobile Advertising 91
Model 211 Theory of Reasoned Action 94
Model 212 Theory of Planned Behaviour 95
Model 213 Technology Acceptance Model 96
Model 42 Research Model of the Study 195
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix 1 Research Questionnaire 274
Appendix II Reliability Analysis and Inter-item Correlation of
Questionnaire Items 287
Appendix III Principal Component Analysis of Variables 292
Appendix IV Measurement and Structural Model for Marketing
Messages and Purchase Behaviour Items 303
Appendix V Measurement and Structural Model for Factors Influencing
Consumer Attitude towards Marketing Messages 308
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
SMS = Short Message Service
MMS = Multimedia Messaging Service
GSM = Global System for Mobile Communications
GPS = Global Positioning System
MMA = Mobile Marketing Association
WAA = Wireless Advertising Association
PDA = Personal Digital Assistant
IMC = Integrated Marketing Communication
GPRS = General Packet Radio Service
MM = Mobile Marketing